There was a time when I thought ESPN's Baseball Tonight was like the L O S T of the all-sports network. It was the definition of niche show -- 30 minutes of the latest baseball highlights, coupled with insightful commentary from likable talking heads. For any person who is a baseball fan, this was appointment viewing, especially since, over the years, Sportscenter has gone away from showing more than 15 seconds of highlights from any given game.And then something happened: I started losing interest. Last year, stalwart Harold Reynolds was fired because he allegedly sexually harassed an ESPN employee. Along with former Phillies star John Kruk (who looked like he was going to eat himself off the borders of my 42 inch television screen) and former Reds star Jeff Brantley (who looked like he was seconds away from starting a bar fight), Reynolds was part of the group of solid major leaguers who brought their specific brand of baseball knowledge to the telecast.
To replace Reynolds, ESPN tried a number of former players, none of whom could equal Reynolds mix of smarts, wardrobe and unintentional comedy. Then Brantley left to go work on the Reds telecasts. Reeling, it seemed like ESPN decided to give former Mets GM Steve Phillips a much larger role on the program.
This was a mistake.





